I always liked the Fright Check table in GURPS and noticed there wasn't an official one for Fudge so I made my own. It is decidedly less intricate and therefore a bit more Fudge-y.
Here's how you use it:
| Failed by | Result | [+] flavor | [ ] flavor | [-] flavor |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | Nothing | cool & collected | cool | collected |
| -1 | No actions for 1 round | stunned | scream | histrionics |
| -2 | Escape by closest means | run | run screaming | drop everything & run screaming |
| -3 | Immobile until "save ends" (make fortitude/health check round-by round) | dry heave | catatonic | faint |
| -4 or worse | -1 to all rolls until cleaned up + mockery | vomit | wet yourself | soil yourself |